Brooklyn Water Bagel

Paul Hawkins 3 months ago

I usually love this place but I ordered the avocado bagel to go today for my girlfriend and when I got home and opened it, it looked absolutely nothing like the photos. I don’t know why they thought it was acceptable to give it to us like this Edit: Lol an AI response from the restaurant is crazy...

Jessica Abrams 3 months ago

I've been a regular customer for quite a while and have always loved this shop, but what really impressed me recently was the customer service. I reached out with a concern and was simply hoping to provide some feedback. Enrique personally called me back, took the time to listen, explained what was going on, and went above and beyond to make things right. It was clear that he genuinely cares about both his customers and the quality of the experience they have. In a world where it's easy for businesses to ignore feedback, it was refreshing to be heard and treated with such kindness and professionalism. That level of customer service is rare these days and is exactly why I'll continue supporting this business. Thank you, Enrique, for taking the time to listen and for caring enough to make a difference.

Ben Adamo a year ago

I give Brooklyn Water Bagel two-thumbs up. Their bagel sandwiches are about $8 - 12. The bagels are made right in front of you and the ingredients all taste fresh. My girlfriend got an awesome cheese pull from her Greenpoint bagel sandwich. I got The Brooklyn and thought it was an excellent bagel sandwich. I'm not sure what else I could ask for out of a bagel place. If you are looking for a dine-in place, though, Water Bagel might not be it. It's a bit small and if it's a busy morning, it can get a bit cramped. The staff are friendly but if you aren't looking for human interaction they do have a clanker who will take your order.

Vern Renzette a year ago

The bagel sandwiches here are pretty delicious and the prices are fair, about $7.50 for a bagel, and each came heartily topped with their respective ingredients. We got our bagels and the first remark my boyfriend made was about how absolutely hefty the bag was. Not only were the sandwiches fat as hell, but they were also nice and warm, and pre-cut down the middle. We got: 1 Greenpoint (egg, spinach, mushrooms, and swiss), and 1 Brooklyn (egg, bacon, sausage, and cheddar) and split them so we each ate half of one and half of the other. Both were great. If you love a classic egg and sausage sandwich, the Brooklyn is a perfect representation of the simple but timeless classic. Compared to a sausage, egg, and cheese from Dunkin', this was far superior (although priced slightly higher as expected). The atmosphere was sort of chain-ey which is usually a turn-off for me, and they also offer a variety of coffees that look like they would be sold alongside other ultra-processed flavored coffees at a larger chain like Wawa or Dunkin'. For me, this isn't what I'm looking for, but I've heard others love their coffee flavors and that the ice cubes are made from frozen coffee. The tables were

Nickolas Peters a year ago

Great bagel and friendly staff! That’s your place to grab a bagel sandwich and a delicious coffee. It’s fast, with good price, interesting options, and great service. The bagels are fresh, made in there. They even have some not bagel options, with other types of bread, wraps and even a bagel dog (huge pig in a blanket of bagel) which we got and it’s really good. I highly recommend